One of the berries I grew this year was a thornless blackberry known as 'Chester'. Chester is meant to be one of the tastier and more cold hardy of the thornless blackberries.
Unlike some of the varieties of thornless blackberry such as Waldo, Chester is said to be relatively productive and tasty. Also unlike many varieties of blackberry it is legal to grow, sell, propagate, distribute etc Chester blackberries in NSW.
Unfortunately the heat hit at the wrong time and we lost most of the berries, hopefully next year when the plant is larger we get a larger crop. They do taste good, but I far prefer my thornless youngberries.
Days to maturity Thornless Chester Blackberry (Rubus fruticosus species aggregate)
Seeds planted N/A grown from divisions
Germinated N/A
Flowered 26/11/2017 Day 0
Fruit Ripe 06/01/2018 Day 41
Saturday 3 March 2018
Thursday 1 March 2018
Days to Maturity raspberries from seed
Not many people grow raspberries from seed. To be honest, unless you have some reason to grow them from seed it is probably best not to. Most people grow from existing plants, which is far easier, much faster, and far more reliable.
Raspberries are not the easiest seed to germinate, or the easiest seedling to care for. Most, if not all, are highly heterozygous, meaning that each seed will be genetically unique. They take a long time to germinate, they are tiny and take a long time to grow, meaning you have to water them and protect them from slugs, snails and insects over this time. Then the resultant fruit may be delicious or bland or sweet or sour or anywhere in between.
If you are going to grow raspberries from seed you should NEVER EVER buy it from ebay as there are too many thieves on ebay selling fake seeds. Very few seed sellers carry raspberry seed, and many who do make all kinds of dishonest claims about them. This means if you plan to grow it you will need to get fresh raspberries and save the seed yourself.
Knowing all of this, if you still choose to grow raspberries from seed (perhaps you have some interesting breeding project in mind) I thought I would record raspberry days to maturity from seed. I wish I started keeping a record of days to maturity a long time ago.
Days to maturity Red Raspberry (Rubus idaeus) from seed
Seeds planted 16/09/2017 Day 0
Germinated 21/12/2017 Day 96
Flowered Not Yet Flowered - still tiny
Fruit Ripe Not Yet Fruited
Raspberries are not the easiest seed to germinate, or the easiest seedling to care for. Most, if not all, are highly heterozygous, meaning that each seed will be genetically unique. They take a long time to germinate, they are tiny and take a long time to grow, meaning you have to water them and protect them from slugs, snails and insects over this time. Then the resultant fruit may be delicious or bland or sweet or sour or anywhere in between.
If you are going to grow raspberries from seed you should NEVER EVER buy it from ebay as there are too many thieves on ebay selling fake seeds. Very few seed sellers carry raspberry seed, and many who do make all kinds of dishonest claims about them. This means if you plan to grow it you will need to get fresh raspberries and save the seed yourself.
Knowing all of this, if you still choose to grow raspberries from seed (perhaps you have some interesting breeding project in mind) I thought I would record raspberry days to maturity from seed. I wish I started keeping a record of days to maturity a long time ago.
Days to maturity Red Raspberry (Rubus idaeus) from seed
Seeds planted 16/09/2017 Day 0
Germinated 21/12/2017 Day 96
Flowered Not Yet Flowered - still tiny
Fruit Ripe Not Yet Fruited
Raspberry seedling with first true leaf |
Raspberry seedlings next to chilli seedlings - raspberry seedlings are tiny |
Saturday 24 February 2018
Igloo tomato
I
wrote a post about finding seeds from the first tomatoes that I ever
bred. I have grown them twice since then, the first time I was amazed
at how fit for purpose and great they were. The second time I grew them
I decided to record some
stats.
The first tomato variety I bred I have named ‘Igloo’ after my first son. It is a sturdy and productive plant that grew to be well under two feet tall. The Igloo tomato fruit is red and round, this is because at the time I was developing it I only had access to red round tomatoes as breeding stock. I wanted relatively small fruit as large fruit takes longer to ripen and faces more danger of something damaging the fruit before it is picked. Most of the fruits were just over 45 grams in weight, they are relatively uniform.
I didn’t have a great deal of access to water and had to carry manure to fertilise the soil, so I wanted short plants that did not waste resources on growing tall and did not need huge amounts of water. These Igloo tomatoes only grow one to two feet tall, usually around 1 foot tall depending on growing conditions. They don’t appear to be too water hungry but I haven’t tried growing them without watering. All tomatoes need water, don’t let anyone make you think that they don’t.
The taste of Igloo tomato is very
good, probably a bit more sweet than it is sour, but a good mix of
both. If eaten too early they taste ok, if left to ripen properly the
taste is far superior. As with any tomato they are best not
refrigerated
as it impacts on the taste. Also like any other variety of tomato they
taste best when ripened on the plant and grown in much sun and warmth.
Igloo tomato is what would be
considered to be a determinate variety, or possibly semi-determinate, it
sets flowers/fruit at the end of the growing point. Unlike most determinate tomato varieties, once it has set
fruit it tends to put out a few more shoots lower down and starts
again. This means it crops over an extended period. Each flower truss tends to have 16 flowers, some have more but
16 seems very common. Even though you would probably consider them to
be determinate they do ripen over a very long period of time.
I was amazed at how absolutely covered in fruit this small plant was, it was very productive for such a small plant. Rather than estimate the number I decided to count every fruit and record it after I picked it.
Over the summer of 2017/2018 my Igloo tomato has already produced a flush of 242 tomatoes and has started to put out a few more branches and has started to flower again. We lost some tomatoes to insects and birds (and the kids probably picked some that I didn’t know about) so I have not included them in the count.
I didn’t weigh each fruit, but if the average weight is 45 grams this represents a harvest of 10.89 kg of tomatoes from one Igloo tomato plant so far. This is excellent when you consider that the plant took up a small amount of space and was around 1 foot tall.
I sell seeds of Igloo tomato, as well as some other vegetables seeds and perennial vegetable plants on my for sale page.
The first tomato variety I bred I have named ‘Igloo’ after my first son. It is a sturdy and productive plant that grew to be well under two feet tall. The Igloo tomato fruit is red and round, this is because at the time I was developing it I only had access to red round tomatoes as breeding stock. I wanted relatively small fruit as large fruit takes longer to ripen and faces more danger of something damaging the fruit before it is picked. Most of the fruits were just over 45 grams in weight, they are relatively uniform.
Igloo tomato - the first tomato variety I bred |
When I was developing this variety I
lived in a climate with a very short summer, so I wanted fast ripening
small tomatoes. This is one of the earliest ripening tomatoes I have
grown and was the first to ripen of my productive tomatoes
(ie Micro Tom ripened first but doesn’t count). This year it took 147
days from planting the seed to picking the first ripe fruit. When you look at my vegetable days to harvest page you will notice that this is very early. I also
wanted something that would set fruit in the cold, which this variety
does well.
I didn’t have a great deal of access to water and had to carry manure to fertilise the soil, so I wanted short plants that did not waste resources on growing tall and did not need huge amounts of water. These Igloo tomatoes only grow one to two feet tall, usually around 1 foot tall depending on growing conditions. They don’t appear to be too water hungry but I haven’t tried growing them without watering. All tomatoes need water, don’t let anyone make you think that they don’t.
Igloo tomato - absolutely covered in flowers |
Igloo tomato, loaded with unripe fruit |
I was amazed at how absolutely covered in fruit this small plant was, it was very productive for such a small plant. Rather than estimate the number I decided to count every fruit and record it after I picked it.
Over the summer of 2017/2018 my Igloo tomato has already produced a flush of 242 tomatoes and has started to put out a few more branches and has started to flower again. We lost some tomatoes to insects and birds (and the kids probably picked some that I didn’t know about) so I have not included them in the count.
I didn’t weigh each fruit, but if the average weight is 45 grams this represents a harvest of 10.89 kg of tomatoes from one Igloo tomato plant so far. This is excellent when you consider that the plant took up a small amount of space and was around 1 foot tall.
Friday 16 February 2018
Wasabi herb (Diplotaxis erucoides)
It
is not very often that I find a vegetable that I am not familiar with.
Different varieties or new varieties yes, but I generally have grown
and eaten similar things many times before. This time I happened
across something no new to me that the binomial name didn’t even sound
familiar to me.
It was a small an uninteresting looking plant in a nursery labelled as "wasabi salad herb" (Diplotaxis erucoides), the label claimed the plant tastes like wasabi. I had never heard of Diplotaxis before, so I was immediately intrigued.
It was a small an uninteresting looking plant in a nursery labelled as "wasabi salad herb" (Diplotaxis erucoides), the label claimed the plant tastes like wasabi. I had never heard of Diplotaxis before, so I was immediately intrigued.
I really like wasabi, but it sounds difficult to grow and is very expensive to buy. I have plans to attempt to grow it in the future, I have even marked out a spot where I think it should grow, but I am not ready to get one yet. Most ‘wasabi’ paste in shops in Australia contains no actual wasabi but instead is a mix of horseradish, mustard and green food colouring. I grow a purple mustard that is described as being as hot as wasabi, it certainly has the heat but to me it tastes like mustard. That is not really what I am after. I particularly like the complex taste of wasabi, I enjoy wasabi’s heat but would almost prefer that it was slightly less hot.
While I was at the nursery standing in front of this so called wasabi herb plant I surreptitiously picked a small part of leaf, popped it in my mouth, and chewed it. At first it didn’t really taste like anything, then the wasabi taste came through, then the heat. It was nowhere near as hot as real wasabi, and the burn didn’t last long, but the taste was certainly there, as was some of the nose tingling goodness. I couldn’t help myself, I bought a plant and took it home. I didn’t really know what it was, I didn’t know how to grow it or if it would survive, but I figured I could work that out later.
When I got home I looked on the internet, Diplotaxis erucoides is also called wasabi arugula or wild rocket. It is not terribly uncommon, and several online places in Australia currently sell its seeds, but for some reason I had never heard of it. I have asked around some of the growers I know, none of them have grown it either. Diplotaxis erucoides is reasonably common, but no one has ever heard of it, what fun.
Wasabi herb flowers and developing seed pods |
It was super easy to grow, I just watered it when I water everything else and picked the leaves when I wanted to eat them. After I had this plant for a while, and picked and eaten most of its leaves, it stopped growing new leaves. It starting to send up a flower stalk. Being an annual they tend to die after flowering. Saving seeds was simple and growing from seed was also simple. I imagine this would self seed easily and take care of itself if I found it somewhere suitable to grow.
I now have many little wasabi herb plants growing. They don't appear to like the heat of summer, but they are surviving, some are flowering and should produce seed when the time is right. If you like wasabi and haven't grown this little herb before you should give it a try. If I have enough extra seed I should sell it through my for sale page.
I ate most of the leaves and then they started to flower |
Saturday 10 February 2018
Microbats eat 1,200 mosquitoes per hour? No they don't.
Microbats
in Australia don’t eat up to 1,200 mosquitoes in an hour. This is a
common myth that has been spread for far too long by people who should
know better. Like many myths, this one is well meaning but does more harm than good.
Microbats are great, their habitat is shrinking and I think that more people should build and install bat boxes and other artificial shelters for them, I even found some nice free plans here to build one and would like to encourage you to build a few.
Far
too often people are taken in by this microbats consuming huge numbers of mosquitoes nonsense, they build a bat box,
then when it doesn’t reduce the number of mosquitoes at their BBQ they tell
people not to bother building bat boxes. This is where the damage is done.
Let’s
look at the reality of microbats and you can decide if you still want
to build a bat box. Build them because microbats are great, not because
you have misunderstood these creatures and expect them to do something
that is impossible for them to do. I think if you understand the reality of
these lovely little animals that you will be just as likely to build a
roosting box for them but will be far less likely to convince others not
to build them.
In
Australia we have less than 90 species of microbat, there is some
controversy over the actual number. Depending on your location there
may be 1 or 2 that are native to your region, or there may be 30.
Australia
is a big country, not surprisingly it has a lot of diversity in
habitat, vegetation and wildlife. Not surprisingly, different species of Australian microbats have different diets.
Most
species of microbat in Australia don’t eat mosquitoes at all. Several
species of microbat that are native to Australia can and do eat some
mosquitoes, they just don’t eat them very often and when they do they
don’t eat many of them.
Very
few species of microbats in Australia actually eat mosquitoes, most species only eat larger things such as moths, beetles and spiders. Of the few
species of microbat in Australia that ever eat mosquitoes, on any given
night the majority of individuals will not consume any mosquitoes at
all. Of the individual microbats who do eat mosquitoes on a given
night, the vast majority of their diet will usually be made of moths or
beetles, and mosquitoes will only ever be a very
small percentage.
Eastern bentwing bat - picture from Department of Environment and Heritage |
Most
studies that I have read indicate that very few species of microbat
ever eat mosquitoes, but all species of microbat in Australia eat a lot
of moths and beetles. In one study in a QLD grain growing region
it was found that 100% of the diet of microbats was grain weevils
(weevils are a type of beetle). This alone disproves the microbats
making a noticeable difference to the local mosquito population myth. If you have ever been to grain growing regions you will notice that there are a lot of mosquitoes, so microbats could eat them if they wanted. The microbats just prefer to catch larger, slower , more nutritious meals. It doesn't mean that you shouldn't still build a nice box for bats to sleep in, just that they don't eat significant amounts of mosquitoes.
So far I am yet to find any research where mosquitoes made up a large percentage of a microbat’s diet anywhere in Australia. If you are a bat researcher or know of any study that indicates otherwise please let me know as I would love to read it. This has to be a peer reviewed study, not notes someone wrote after claiming to read a study, or some unverifiable and unrepeated observation written for BATS magazine that has been misunderstood and plagiarised by milkwood.
Ever wonder where the microbats eating 1,200 mosquitoes an hour myth first came from? The ridiculously high numbers of mosquitoes potentially being consumed was extrapolated from a student in Sweden who reported once observing a single bat successfully capture “up to 20 mosquitoes in a minute” using a stopwatch. One minute, not an hour, not averaged over an entire night, just one minute with a stopwatch in the field and a best guess. Have you ever watched microbats feeding? This method is far from accurate.
It gets worse, the field observations were made in northern Sweden during the summer where the sun only dips below the horizon for 90 minutes per night. During this time the larger, slower, more nutritious insects were not common. That means that even if this number was accurate it would not be transferable to Australian microbats.
There is no point having a two dimensional simplistic view of the world. In Australia we have different species of microbats than they have in Sweden, many larger and easier to catch food insects are present here, and our nights are far longer. All of this means that even if it were true, this unrealistically high number of mosquitoes being consumed is not applicable in Australia.
Mosquitoes are small and fast and require a lot of energy to catch. Due to their tiny size a mosquito provides very little return on this large investment. It is easier to catch fewer but larger food items and have some time for rest, drinking water, searching for roosting sites, courtship etc. Catching a mosquito every three seconds for hour after hour when there are larger slower food items around just doesn’t happen, it is illogical to ever think that it would. So please don't be taken in by it.
In Australia, mosquitoes are more of a convenient treat for some microbats rather than a staple food, microbats much prefer to eat moths or beetles. Notice how I keep talking about microbats in Australia? I don’t care what happens in other parts of the world, me building a bat box only effects microbats that I may encounter here in Australia.
Why
bother encouraging microbats if they don’t eat many mosquitoes? To put
it bluntly, I attract many animals to my yard that don’t eat mosquitoes
as they have other benefits, why wouldn't I do the same for microbats. Many people
buy insect zappers with those blue lights, they don’t attract
mosquitoes yet it is a thriving industry. Lowering the numbers of moths
and beetles is fantastic and well worth encouraging microbats into your
garden. The microbats don’t just eat the insects,
they also disrupt mating which reduces the number of insect eggs laid which has an even larger effect on pest populations.
Don’t
ever be so gullible that you are fooled into thinking that microbats
only eat pests, they also eat many beneficial arthropods. This is the
same as spiders and birds eat pests but they also eat beneficial
insects. This is nature, there is no way around it, no use in
pretending it isn’t happening.
Strangely
very few studies have been done to see how much of a difference
microbats make in protecting large scale crops from pests. I have heard
of a few studies that claim microbats significantly lower damage
from coddling moth in walnuts, helicoverpa moth in cotton fields, and
grain weevils in grain crops, but would love to read more studies. Again I stress that microbats are great to have around, they just won't make a noticeable difference to the local mosquito population in your back yard.
I
have often wondered if encouraging microbats to live near bee hives
would reduce the damage from wax moth. Would running poultry under the
hives during the day and encouraging microbats at night reduce pests significantly? Unfortunately I
can find no research (or even anecdotal evidence) that has tested this.
I guess people are too caught up in thinking microbats only eat
thousands of mosquitoes per hour that they can’t
think of ways to utilise them to actually reduce pests.
Let me stress that I
want to encourage people to build and install bat boxes. Just remember
that microbats are great to have around, but they won’t make a
noticeable difference to the mosquito population in your area.
Monday 5 February 2018
Meyer Lemon tree from cutting
I have never been a huge fan of lemons. There is little doubt that the lemon is the
poor cousin of the lime. To be
completely honest, I was never a huge fan of growing any citrus tree, recently
this has changed.
I have also planted some meyer lemon seeds. I know full well that each of these seeds
will be different to the parent, most won’t be as good, but I may end up with
something even better.
Maybe one day I will sell lemon trees through my for sale page.
Lemons from my tree |
We have had a few citrus trees in the past, some
oranges and a few different lemons, they were slow growing, unproductive,
demanded huge quantities of water, they died back in the heat, they died back
in the cold, branches died from lack of water even though I mulched heavily and
watered each afternoon, they seemed to attract every pest known to man, then if
you pampered them and watered them and protected them from the sheep and they
actually set fruit it was pithy and seedy and more often than not completely filled with
fruit fly.
When we moved to our current house it had a lemon
tree. I am happy to say that due to our
harsh winters the fruit fly don’t do well here.
The lemon tree had some fruit on it that was ripe, some that was over
ripe and rotting, and some that was mummified and appeared diseased, all of
which needed to be picked. I reluctantly
picked the fruit while planning to remove the tree and eventually replace it
with something else. As we had some ripe
lemons we used them, no point wasting them, and found it to be the best lemon I
have ever eaten.
My lemon tree produces fruit that is smaller than
the lemons I can buy from markets, it had a very thin skin with little to no
noticeable pith, it was extremely juicy, it was strangely sweet for a lemon, and it seemed relatively productive even though it has clearly
not been taken care of. While I think it
is sour some of my kids can eat it straight off the tree or drink its juice
without screwing up their faces too much.
Meyer lemons |
After a little research I found that this is a meyer
lemon. Meyer lemons are different to
regular lemons in a number of ways.
The Meyer lemon tree was ‘discovered’ in China in
the early 1900s (possibly 1908) by Frank Meyer, who was an agricultural
explorer. It is thought to be a natural
cross between a lemon and a bitter orange, the exact parentage is debated
somewhat. Like most citrus it does have
thorns when young, but as the tree ages it tends to grow less thorns or no
thorns. It is sweeter than most lemons,
juicier than most lemons, and has a thinner skin than most lemons.
This thin skin means that meyer lemons are more
difficult to pick, ship, and store for extended periods. As a home gardener I don’t store anything in
warehouses for extended periods, I don’t ship fresh fruit across the globe, and
I am not picking for hours at a time so can take the care required not to
damage them too badly. So having thin skin is not a bad thing for me.
This past year I decided to weigh the fruit my
little tree produced, in one season it produced over 50 kg of ripe lemons. This coming season it looks like it will
produce a lot less. If I remember I will
try to weigh it, but it is a lot of work weighing fruit that is picked over
several months so I may not bother.
Meyer lemon tree cutting |
Being such a great tree I decided to grow another
one from a cutting. Who would have
thought I would ever consider doing that when I was originally planning to just
rip out the tree!
Meyer lemon tree cutting with roots |
I looked on the internet and many people say it is
impossible for home gardeners to grow lemons from cuttings, or they give strict
instructions that they claim must be followed, others claim you need to use
rooting hormones or expensive cloning thingies.
I didn’t do any of that. Perhaps
I just got lucky, but for me growing a lemon tree from a cutting really wasn’t that difficult to do.
I cut off a small branch, loosely tied a
plastic bag over the end, and kept it in some water until it grew roots. You can easily see the roots in the pictures above. Once the roots were visible I removed the
plastic bag and planted it into a pot of soil.
Then I forgot to water it for a while, and had it in too much shade, and
so forth, but it is still alive and growing.
Meyer lemon tree cutting is now a proper little tree - look how much it has grown! |
I also know it can take a few years before the tree
is old enough to flower and fruit. It
will be interesting to see how many years it actually takes.
If you plan to grow lemons from seeds it is easier
to grow from fresh seeds as dry seeds don’t seem to do as well. Perhaps they die when dried, perhaps they go
dormant and take longer to sprout, I don’t really know or care, I just know it
is easier to germinate fresh seeds.
I found web sites describing how to grow lemons from
seeds who claim “non-organic lemons often contain non-germinating seeds” and
“Make sure you purchase an organic lemon since some non-organic lemon seeds may
be “duds”, incapable of germinating”.
This is utterly ridiculous.
Please ignore anything you hear from people who spread this kind of
misinformation.
Both organically grown and non-organically grown
lemon seeds have an equal chance of germinating and growing. My tree, much like everything in my yard, is
organically grown, but if I applied synthetic fertiliser it would not alter the
ability of the seeds to germinate.
Perhaps these people are misunderstanding what they have heard about vegetables? Maybe they are misunderstanding hybrid sterility due to incompatible ploidy levels, or cytoplasmic male sterility? Obviously they wont grow true to type as it is Meyer lemons are a hybrid to begin with. The parents of meyer lemons clearly had the same ploidy level, the fruit is not seedless, they self-pollinate and produces viable seeds, so there is no reason that organic will have more viable seeds than non-organic.
Perhaps these people are misunderstanding what they have heard about vegetables? Maybe they are misunderstanding hybrid sterility due to incompatible ploidy levels, or cytoplasmic male sterility? Obviously they wont grow true to type as it is Meyer lemons are a hybrid to begin with. The parents of meyer lemons clearly had the same ploidy level, the fruit is not seedless, they self-pollinate and produces viable seeds, so there is no reason that organic will have more viable seeds than non-organic.
I find it frustrating that people spread these kinds
of lies. Most are well meaning and
either confused or are doing it to try and convince people to grow
organically. I grow things organically, and
I encourage others to grow organically, but I like to encourage by providing
information rather than through making up illogical lies and pretending that
things are different than they really are.
People who spread this nonsense are doing far more harm than good.
I grew my lemon seeds by getting some seeds from
some lemons that we were juicing, and planting them in a punnet of soil. I kept this punnet moist, mostly forgot about
it, figured it had been so long that they weren’t going to grow, and they grew
when they were ready. I only planted the
fatter and more developed seeds. I
didn’t expect many to grow so I put a fair few in. Unfortunately I didn’t count them but I am
guessing that most germinated.
So far all my little lemon tree seedlings have been
burned intense sunlight, they have not been watered enough, they are in poor
soil, some were pelted with large hail, but
they are all surviving. I don’t have
much space so don’t plan to keep many, lemon seedlings are not very winter
hardy so perhaps I will wait and keep the largest ones that survive winter.
Maybe one day I will sell lemon trees through my for sale page.
Thursday 1 February 2018
Breeding Superior Slow Bolt Coriander
Coriander (Coriandrum sativum) is a herb that you either love or hate. This does not store well or transport well or dry well, and hydroponically grown coriander that you can get in supermarkets often taste weak, so for those of us who love coriander we must grow it ourselves.
Most people who grow coriander to harvest leaves (the Americans call the leaves 'cilantro') complain that they bolt too easily. It often feels like any stress from transplant shock, or hot weather, or a change in the weather, or under watering, or over watering, or even looking at them wrong makes them stop growing leaves and start flowering. Buying so-called ‘slow bolt’ varieties often makes no noticeable difference as these varieties have been grown by the seed company and no selective pressure has been placed on them for reluctance to flower.
I
was given seed of several different varieties of coriander collected
from several different countries, plus I already had some that I had
grown previously and added selective pressure to. I grew all
nine varieties being careful to prevent them from crossing, and while
each variety was nice and clearly different from one another none of
them really thrives in my climate. The leaf shape and size varied
considerably among them, the size and number of seeds
was very different between varieties, but they all taste and smell much the
same. I don’t have the time or space to grow nine substandard varieties and
keep them all pure, and I really don’t have space to add the selective
pressure required to improve each of the varieties separately,
so I had a difficult decision to make.
Rather
than keeping the lines pure and separate, putting in effort to maintain
purity, and having nothing that performs overly well here, I decided to
plant all of them and produce a mass cross. They are very
distinct varieties, originating from several different countries,
meaning there is a lot of genetic diversity among them. Inbreeding
depression will be eliminated from my population through this mass cross
event. From the mass cross or grex, which is comprised
of many different potential f1 crosses, I will grow out and allow
them to cross as they see fit, all while culling.
I did three staggered plantings of several seeds from all the varieties to ensure that each variety will flower and cross with each other variety. It seems strange to be allowing coriander to flower, and not to be culling, but this is only the start. Every year from now there will be culling, as well as back crossing to the previous year seeds.
If I cull hard each year I should be able to create a new variety or landrace of coriander that performs far better in this climate. While I feel bad that once these have crossed I have no way to get these varieties back, which means that many of these varieties may well go extinct, the end result should be superior to anything I currently have access to. I only have small numbers of seed of the original varieties left, but if you are a seed saver group and want a few seeds from the original strains and want to keep them pure please let me know before it is too late.
When breeding it is important to know what to cull for, to make some culling rules, and to strictly follow those rules. I plan to cull for firstly amount/size of leaves as that is what I want to harvest from the plants, there is no use having plants that take forever to flower if they don't produce many leaves. Then I will select for reluctance to bolt as the yield is reduced if they stress and flower too easily. Then I will select for number of seed produced, then large size of seeds.
I want to end up with plants that produce lots of leaves and are simple to grow and save seed from each year. Producing many seeds means I can produce many plants, and large seeds are easier to work with and tend to remain viable for longer, but leaves are the crop here so that is where the main selective pressure is to be added.
Most of these original varieties are 'slow bolt' and 'long standing' and 'giant' leaf varieties, some from hot climates, others from cold climates, this gives a strong yet wide genetic base with which to work.
Most people who grow coriander to harvest leaves (the Americans call the leaves 'cilantro') complain that they bolt too easily. It often feels like any stress from transplant shock, or hot weather, or a change in the weather, or under watering, or over watering, or even looking at them wrong makes them stop growing leaves and start flowering. Buying so-called ‘slow bolt’ varieties often makes no noticeable difference as these varieties have been grown by the seed company and no selective pressure has been placed on them for reluctance to flower.
Most
people adopt one of two responses to this issue, they either stop
growing coriander as it is too difficult/low yielding, or they save seed
from the best plants each year and add selective pressure for slow
bolting plants. These are both valid and sensible responses.
Recently I
read a paper written by an overseas seed research facility that said
“Selection is the most common breeding procedure used in coriander and
crossing is non-existent”.
I encourage people to add deliberate selective pressure when saving seeds, I certainly do this myself. Common sense tells you that if you plant seed of the slower bolting plants (and cull the early flowering ones) then the next generation will be slower bolting. The main issue with adding selective pressure coriander is that you are working with a small inbred population of plants that have very little diversity in their genetic makeup, so progress is made but it is slow progress. To really create slow bolting coriander crossing different varieties is essential. So that is what I have done.
I encourage people to add deliberate selective pressure when saving seeds, I certainly do this myself. Common sense tells you that if you plant seed of the slower bolting plants (and cull the early flowering ones) then the next generation will be slower bolting. The main issue with adding selective pressure coriander is that you are working with a small inbred population of plants that have very little diversity in their genetic makeup, so progress is made but it is slow progress. To really create slow bolting coriander crossing different varieties is essential. So that is what I have done.
Coriander mass cross, I had another bed of these behind and another one next to this to ensure every variety would cross with every variety |
Coriander mass cross, even this tiny some are already flowering due to the heat |
I did three staggered plantings of several seeds from all the varieties to ensure that each variety will flower and cross with each other variety. It seems strange to be allowing coriander to flower, and not to be culling, but this is only the start. Every year from now there will be culling, as well as back crossing to the previous year seeds.
If I cull hard each year I should be able to create a new variety or landrace of coriander that performs far better in this climate. While I feel bad that once these have crossed I have no way to get these varieties back, which means that many of these varieties may well go extinct, the end result should be superior to anything I currently have access to. I only have small numbers of seed of the original varieties left, but if you are a seed saver group and want a few seeds from the original strains and want to keep them pure please let me know before it is too late.
I have been
harvesting the leaves even from substandard plants, so I am no worse
off than just growing all of the different varieties and keeping them
pure, and I should never end up with something as bad as I
started with. This first year I have allowed all of the varieties to flower and cross, I have even done a second planting of all the varieties to increase chances of crossing all the different varieties with each other.
After this first year, when the lower quality plants begin to bolt they will be
culled and not allowed to flower, so each generation the genepool
becomes superior to the previous one.
Coriander |
When breeding it is important to know what to cull for, to make some culling rules, and to strictly follow those rules. I plan to cull for firstly amount/size of leaves as that is what I want to harvest from the plants, there is no use having plants that take forever to flower if they don't produce many leaves. Then I will select for reluctance to bolt as the yield is reduced if they stress and flower too easily. Then I will select for number of seed produced, then large size of seeds.
I want to end up with plants that produce lots of leaves and are simple to grow and save seed from each year. Producing many seeds means I can produce many plants, and large seeds are easier to work with and tend to remain viable for longer, but leaves are the crop here so that is where the main selective pressure is to be added.
Most of these original varieties are 'slow bolt' and 'long standing' and 'giant' leaf varieties, some from hot climates, others from cold climates, this gives a strong yet wide genetic base with which to work.
When
I have finished tinkering with this improved coriander variety I may
sell seeds through my for sale page. Currently I am selling the mass cross seeds and allow others the opportunity
to create their own new variety that suits their climate. These will display a wide range of genetic diversity, all will taste and smell like normal coriander. If you buy these please cull hard, ONLY save seed from the slowest to flower, that way you will create a variety of coriander that will be productive and slow to flower in your garden.
Thursday 25 January 2018
Days to harvest Rhubarb from seed
I was sent a few different varieties of rhubarb seed that was originally collected from different countries.
Very few people grow rhubarb from seed. It is said to be too difficult, and it is said to take too long. yet no one ever tells you how long it actually takes.
Most varieties of rhubarb, even if it self pollinates, will not grow true to type and you will not get anything similar to the parent plant. Each rhubarb variety that I was sent was said to breed true, which I find almost impossible to believe given the polyploid nature of rhubarb.
Each set of seeds looked different to one another, some larger and some smaller. Each set of seedlings did show a remarkable lack of diversity from one another from that group, yet each group was very different from the others. Even at cotyledon stage it was simple to tell each group from all the others.
Other than one variety collected from Korea, which I am not convinced is rhubarb or even a species of Rheum, all of these rhubarb varieties went dormant over winter and re-sprouted in spring.
The largest was a variety originally collected in China. It was the largest right from the start. The others are not yet ready to harvest. Some are closer to harvest than others. They have all grown a lot since the photo was taken. They have also been battered by the heat and shredded by hail, gone dormant over winter and resprouted in Spring.
Days to maturity Rhubarb (Rheum rhabarbarum)
Seeds planted 04/11/2016 Day 0
Germinated ??/??/2016 Day ? Oh why didn't I record this!
Harvest start 14/01/2018 Roughly 14 months from seed planted to first harvest
Flowering ??/10/2018 Roughly 23 months after seed planted (I removed the flower stalk)
Considering that when you buy rhubarb crowns it is not advisable to harvest in the first year, growing from seed didn't really take much longer. Time will tell which ones are worth keeping.
I also listed the days to harvest from seed for a heap of different vegetables, if you are interested please click here.
Very few people grow rhubarb from seed. It is said to be too difficult, and it is said to take too long. yet no one ever tells you how long it actually takes.
Most varieties of rhubarb, even if it self pollinates, will not grow true to type and you will not get anything similar to the parent plant. Each rhubarb variety that I was sent was said to breed true, which I find almost impossible to believe given the polyploid nature of rhubarb.
Each set of seeds looked different to one another, some larger and some smaller. Each set of seedlings did show a remarkable lack of diversity from one another from that group, yet each group was very different from the others. Even at cotyledon stage it was simple to tell each group from all the others.
Other than one variety collected from Korea, which I am not convinced is rhubarb or even a species of Rheum, all of these rhubarb varieties went dormant over winter and re-sprouted in spring.
The largest was a variety originally collected in China. It was the largest right from the start. The others are not yet ready to harvest. Some are closer to harvest than others. They have all grown a lot since the photo was taken. They have also been battered by the heat and shredded by hail, gone dormant over winter and resprouted in Spring.
Days to maturity Rhubarb (Rheum rhabarbarum)
Seeds planted 04/11/2016 Day 0
Germinated ??/??/2016 Day ? Oh why didn't I record this!
Harvest start 14/01/2018 Roughly 14 months from seed planted to first harvest
Flowering ??/10/2018 Roughly 23 months after seed planted (I removed the flower stalk)
Some of the rhubarb varieties. Left to right seed collected from: China, Poland, Finland, Germany |
Considering that when you buy rhubarb crowns it is not advisable to harvest in the first year, growing from seed didn't really take much longer. Time will tell which ones are worth keeping.
I also listed the days to harvest from seed for a heap of different vegetables, if you are interested please click here.
Tuesday 16 January 2018
How to grow skirret from seed
Skirret
plants will not cross pollinate with anything other than skirret, so
saving seed is easy. Skirret flowers in characteristic umbels that
appear to be loved by all kinds of pollinators from beneficial wasps
to flies to beetles to ants to native bees and even honey bees, so
pollination is never problematic. Seed grown skirret displays a
surprising amount of diversity which is great for breeding improved
plants with thicker roots. I normally plant skirret seed in spring, this year I have sown some in summer and it also appears to be growing well.
Planting
skirret seed in spring will yield a small crop of edible sized roots, a
few tiny offsets to plant out, as well as more seed before the end of
autumn, even in shorter climates. First year roots tend to
be thin and delicious, if you can leave some they will be far thicker
the following year. Planting a tiny skirret offset gives a far larger
plant with thicker roots than seed grown plants. This winter I should
take a comparison photo of seed grown skirret,
offset grown skirret and older skirret plants.
The
main pests I have seen with skirret are slugs and snails, the tiny
seedlings may need a little protection until they get larger which is
why I often grow skirret seedlings in a pot. Much like any seedling
things like earwigs and slaters may kill them when very small. I am
yet to see any pest bother a large skirret plant. I assume rabbits,
ducks, sheep etc would eat skirret plants to death due to the high sugar
content.
Unlike
many other root crops skirret does not appear to dislike being
transplanted. Skirret likes to be protected from the sun for a few days
after transplanting, otherwise the leaves sometimes wilt. I cram
skirret
in to any space I have and get good crops but the more space you can
give them the better, most people plant about 30 cm apart or 9 per
square meter.
Few places sell skirret seed in Australia and even fewer sell skirret plants. I sell skirret seed all year and skirret offsets over winter through my for sale page.
Skirret: normal plants on left, offset grown plants on right |
One year old skirret plants - each skirret plant produces several offsets |
Skirret
seeds are very tiny and germination is normally very simple. I am told
that skirret seed remains viable for anywhere from 3 to 10+ years.
While I normally get great germination I am told that germination
rates can fall below 75% even with fresh seed. To cover against this I
only sell the freshest seed I have and I put extra seed in the packets
so you will easily be able to grow 20 or more plants. I have read that
temperatures of 10 C to 22 C are best for
germination but have never paid much attention to this.
I
plant skirret seed either in pots of soil or in an empty garden bed
with no weeds. I normally scatter the seed over the soil surface and
water well. I don’t cover the seed as it is so tiny and the seedling
may not be able to grow to the surface. I am also not sure if skirret
needs light to improve germination. From here I never let it dry out
and in a week or two I normally see seedlings start to pop up. If it
rains the seedlings seem to germinate and grow
faster, but that may be my imagination.
Skirret offsets, they aren't big |
Once
the skirret seedlings have a few true leaves and are large enough to
handle you can transplant them where they are to grow. Even if seeds
were sown in the garden they will still likely need transplanting
as watering tends to move seeds and clump them together rather than
leave them to grow nicely spaced. You don’t have to transplant them if
you don’t want to as they will survive and still produce a crop.
One dormant skirret offset, it doesn't have roots yet |
Skirret
thrives in cool climates and loves water but it is a survivor that is
remarkably adaptable. I grew it in a hot arid climate where it could
not survive in the garden by keeping it in a pot of soil in a
bucket that I would fill with water each morning and afternoon. Each
year the skirret plants get larger, both taller and wider. Each year
the skirret plants produce more offsets, more seed, and fatter roots.
Skirret roots from two year old plants |
When
the skirret dies down it is time to harvest roots. I have only grown
skirret in frosty areas so don’t know if it dies down in areas of warm
winters. Skirret roots do not store well once dug so I dig them
up as needed. Any small ones that I leave behind or any that I miss
will just be larger and fatter next year.
Location:
Australia
Saturday 13 January 2018
Days to maturity Thornless Youngberry
One of the berries I grew this year was a thornless youngberry.
Youngberries are one of the many hybrid berries that have raspberry and blackberry in their parentage. These are not GM, the first ones were bred about 100 years ago.
These things taste amazing, much like a boysenberry, but are smaller and more productive. They have no thorns on the canes (botanically they are known as prickles) and are strong vigorous growers.
Days to maturity Thornless Youngberry (Rubus sp)
Seeds planted N/A grown from divisions
Germinated N/A
Flowered 25/10/2017 Day 0
Fruit Ripe 07/12/2017 Day 43
I have added this to a larger list of vegetable days to harvest from seed.
Youngberries are one of the many hybrid berries that have raspberry and blackberry in their parentage. These are not GM, the first ones were bred about 100 years ago.
These things taste amazing, much like a boysenberry, but are smaller and more productive. They have no thorns on the canes (botanically they are known as prickles) and are strong vigorous growers.
Days to maturity Thornless Youngberry (Rubus sp)
Seeds planted N/A grown from divisions
Germinated N/A
Flowered 25/10/2017 Day 0
Fruit Ripe 07/12/2017 Day 43
I have added this to a larger list of vegetable days to harvest from seed.
Thornless youngberry |
Thornless youngberry |
Thursday 11 January 2018
Golden Raspberry plants in Australia
A while ago
Diggers club advertised what they claimed to be an exclusive yellow
fruited raspberry plant. They looked and sounded amazing!
“Diggers gold” raspberry plants were listed on their web site, it was listed in their printed catalogues, at first they were only for Diggers members but eventually it was sold through their shops, and it was sold through other stores that carry their line of plants. The stock photos of yellow raspberries they used looked amazing, and their embellished and fanciful description of the plant sounded great. Diggers arrogantly renamed this variety to ‘Diggers gold’ even though they had not bred it and had never actually grown them, not even once. I am not sure if they bought the naming rights or if they just decided to rename it to make it more marketable like they do with so many other plants and seeds that they sell. This level of contempt and arrogance is typical of many of my experiences with Diggers Club.
Here is the irony, I love this part: the raspberry variety that Diggers actually had, the one that they renamed to be “Diggers Gold”, was actually a red fruited raspberry.
If you looked on Diggers club facebook page you either see comments from people who say they can’t wait for them to fruit, or comments complaining that they had red fruit. Not a single comment on there said that they grew yellow fruit. Not one. It certainly appears that Diggers did not sell a single yellow fruited raspberry.
“Diggers gold” raspberry plants were listed on their web site, it was listed in their printed catalogues, at first they were only for Diggers members but eventually it was sold through their shops, and it was sold through other stores that carry their line of plants. The stock photos of yellow raspberries they used looked amazing, and their embellished and fanciful description of the plant sounded great. Diggers arrogantly renamed this variety to ‘Diggers gold’ even though they had not bred it and had never actually grown them, not even once. I am not sure if they bought the naming rights or if they just decided to rename it to make it more marketable like they do with so many other plants and seeds that they sell. This level of contempt and arrogance is typical of many of my experiences with Diggers Club.
Here is the irony, I love this part: the raspberry variety that Diggers actually had, the one that they renamed to be “Diggers Gold”, was actually a red fruited raspberry.
If you looked on Diggers club facebook page you either see comments from people who say they can’t wait for them to fruit, or comments complaining that they had red fruit. Not a single comment on there said that they grew yellow fruit. Not one. It certainly appears that Diggers did not sell a single yellow fruited raspberry.
Diggers
club sold these ‘diggers gold’ raspberry plants to many, many home gardeners.
A year or so later when they had red fruit a reasonable number of these
people complained because they did not get what they paid
for. Diggers sent replacement plants to most people who complained,
and they grew the plants on for another year and a half, only to have
red fruit again. For some people, this happened more times and they
never got what they paid for. Some people were
tricked to think that fruit colour was influenced by growing conditions (which it is not)
or somehow they were to blame. Others were offered credit on their next purchase. I almost bought a Diggers membership just so I could get a golden raspberry, I am so glad that I didn't fall for their lies again.
I have heard people try to justify all of this and say that they still got raspberries - unfortunately that isn’t good enough. If I wanted to buy an inferior and unnamed random variety of raspberry I would do that and not pay the high prices and inflated and unjustified postage cost that Diggers has. People made space for these things when they could have grown something far better. It is the time spent growing the wrong thing that is the biggest loss – you can’t get back time.
You would have thought that with such a large company and paying inflated prices for something they claim to be exclusive that you would have some assurance in actually getting what you paid for, apparently not with Diggers club. With the Diggers club you don’t always get what you pay for. Rest assured, Diggers doesn’t currently list ‘Diggers gold raspberries’. Perhaps one day they will rename another variety of raspberry to be ‘Diggers gold’ and maybe it will be yellow fruited? Perhaps one day Diggers club will have a yellow raspberry and rename it to be something else or add 'Clive' to the cultivar name? I wouldn’t risk buying from them though.
Yellow fruited raspberries do exist in Australia
Some people had such a bad experience with Diggers club and spent so much time growing diggers gold (red fruited) raspberries that they think yellow raspberries don’t actually exist. I am happy to say that yellow fruiting raspberries do exist in Australia, I grow them. I paid a small fortune to get a few plants from someone trustworthy (ie not Diggers club or ebay) and it was worth it.
My golden raspberries
My golden raspberry plants are an un-named variety, they looked very strong and healthy. I planted the golden raspberries in two different positions to ensure that they would not die off. Apparently they were well suited to both of these positions as they have all done well and spread nicely.
Like many other varieties of raspberry they have
thorns (botanically these are 'prickles'), and it is a floricane variety,
meaning that it will not flower or fruit on current year growth. It
needs previous year growth to flower and fruit.
This is why it often takes a while to get the first fruit but
once they do fruit once they should fruit each year from then onwards. My golden raspberries fruited around Christmas time and spread out the harvest for a few weeks. I wrote another post on golden raspberry days to maturity.
This variety also has the habit of spreading roots under the soil and growing extra canes from the root tips. This means that an investment in a few plants can quickly expand and fill in an entire patch. I love how raspberries do this.
My golden raspberries taste much like red raspberries, except they are much sweeter. They smell sweet and fruity, I really love the way they smell. The fruit is super soft and delicate, this is perfect for home gardeners who will carry the raspberries to where they are to be eaten, but not great if you plan to transport it to supermarkets across the country, which is why you don't see many yellow raspberries in the shops.
The colour of golden raspberries is pretty remarkable, I am no photographer so my pictures don't do them justice. They range from a bright golden yellow to a richer yellow on the same plant. Birds seem to ignore the yellow fruit, then again birds seem to ignore red raspberries too. Insects, slugs and children on the other hand do not ignore them and find them irresistible. My kids comment on how they love the fruity smell of golden raspberries.
The plants seem reasonably productive and just as hardy as other varieties. They don't appear to grow any taller or shorter than my other varieties. In fact, when they are not fruiting I would not be able to tell them apart from many of the other varieties I grow.
I have heard people try to justify all of this and say that they still got raspberries - unfortunately that isn’t good enough. If I wanted to buy an inferior and unnamed random variety of raspberry I would do that and not pay the high prices and inflated and unjustified postage cost that Diggers has. People made space for these things when they could have grown something far better. It is the time spent growing the wrong thing that is the biggest loss – you can’t get back time.
You would have thought that with such a large company and paying inflated prices for something they claim to be exclusive that you would have some assurance in actually getting what you paid for, apparently not with Diggers club. With the Diggers club you don’t always get what you pay for. Rest assured, Diggers doesn’t currently list ‘Diggers gold raspberries’. Perhaps one day they will rename another variety of raspberry to be ‘Diggers gold’ and maybe it will be yellow fruited? Perhaps one day Diggers club will have a yellow raspberry and rename it to be something else or add 'Clive' to the cultivar name? I wouldn’t risk buying from them though.
My golden raspberries look great |
Yellow fruited raspberries do exist in Australia
Some people had such a bad experience with Diggers club and spent so much time growing diggers gold (red fruited) raspberries that they think yellow raspberries don’t actually exist. I am happy to say that yellow fruiting raspberries do exist in Australia, I grow them. I paid a small fortune to get a few plants from someone trustworthy (ie not Diggers club or ebay) and it was worth it.
My golden raspberries |
My golden raspberries
My golden raspberry plants are an un-named variety, they looked very strong and healthy. I planted the golden raspberries in two different positions to ensure that they would not die off. Apparently they were well suited to both of these positions as they have all done well and spread nicely.
My golden raspberries starting to ripen |
This variety also has the habit of spreading roots under the soil and growing extra canes from the root tips. This means that an investment in a few plants can quickly expand and fill in an entire patch. I love how raspberries do this.
My golden raspberries taste much like red raspberries, except they are much sweeter. They smell sweet and fruity, I really love the way they smell. The fruit is super soft and delicate, this is perfect for home gardeners who will carry the raspberries to where they are to be eaten, but not great if you plan to transport it to supermarkets across the country, which is why you don't see many yellow raspberries in the shops.
The colour of golden raspberries is pretty remarkable, I am no photographer so my pictures don't do them justice. They range from a bright golden yellow to a richer yellow on the same plant. Birds seem to ignore the yellow fruit, then again birds seem to ignore red raspberries too. Insects, slugs and children on the other hand do not ignore them and find them irresistible. My kids comment on how they love the fruity smell of golden raspberries.
The plants seem reasonably productive and just as hardy as other varieties. They don't appear to grow any taller or shorter than my other varieties. In fact, when they are not fruiting I would not be able to tell them apart from many of the other varieties I grow.
Golden raspberry: something took a bite out of this one |
The colour gets a tiny bit darker if left to ripen longer |
Golden raspberry plants are difficult to find, please NEVER buy seeds from ebay as you will be sent seeds but not yellow fruited raspberry seed. By the time you work it out, assuming that you get any to germinate, it will be too late to do anything.
Please don't buy from Diggers club if they ever claim to have golden raspberries again. The utter contempt that they showed in their first botched attempt (and the many other times they have disappointed customers with similar disrespectful stunts) should be enough to warn you off buying from them.
Over winter when my plants are dormant I will hopefully have a few extra that I can sell through my for sale page. If all goes well I should be able to sell a few each winter. Unfortunately I can't offer pre-purchasing as I would hate to have a crop failure or something and not be able to come through.
Golden raspberries starting to ripen |
Location:
Australia
Monday 8 January 2018
Oyster mushrooms on cardboard
I wrote another blog on how I grew oyster mushrooms on newspaper.
Another way I grew them was on torn up pieces of cardboard in an ice cream container. This method was fast, but the mushrooms were small and it was difficult to keep the right amount of moisture in the cardboard. It would have been better to use a larger container and have some holes in the sides of it. I didn't think to take any pictures of this.
Days to Maturity Oyster mushrooms on cardboard
27/06/2017 damp cardboard inoculated with oyster mushroom stems Day 0
01/07/2017 noticeable mycelium growth Day 4
16/07/2017 cardboard fully colonised, more added Day 19
24/08/2017 fruiting (about 2 months) Day 58
28/09/2017 fruiting again Day 93
Another way I grew them was on torn up pieces of cardboard in an ice cream container. This method was fast, but the mushrooms were small and it was difficult to keep the right amount of moisture in the cardboard. It would have been better to use a larger container and have some holes in the sides of it. I didn't think to take any pictures of this.
Days to Maturity Oyster mushrooms on cardboard
27/06/2017 damp cardboard inoculated with oyster mushroom stems Day 0
01/07/2017 noticeable mycelium growth Day 4
16/07/2017 cardboard fully colonised, more added Day 19
24/08/2017 fruiting (about 2 months) Day 58
28/09/2017 fruiting again Day 93
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)