Mudflower: Yellow vs Red vs Black Raspberries in Australia: Taste, Yield and Growing Differences

Yellow, red and black raspberries all look similar, but they differ significantly in flavour, productivity, growth habits and management. After growing all three in my garden for several years, here is how they compare

A number of years ago I bred a new variety of red raspberry. I acknowledge that I am biased - I like this raspberry (Rubus idaeus). It is genetically thornless, very vigorous, incredibly productive, produces dozens of flowers per cluster, fruits multiple times per year, and tastes nicely sweet. This red raspberry performs better in my garden than any other raspberry variety I have grown. I am told it does not grow as well in subtropical gardens.

I eventually tracked down a yellow raspberry (Rubus idaeus) and did a little breeding with this too. This one has thorns (prickles). It only crops once or twice per year and has flowers in clusters of about half a dozen. The berries are pretty, they smell divine, and it tastes very sweet. What it lacks of the typical raspberry flavour it makes up for in delicate floral notes. I need to do more breeding with this to create a thornless primocane version.

After some years I got a black raspberry (Rubus occidentalis). This is a different species of raspberry to the red (or yellow) raspberry. It is not a blackberry. It is not a loganberry. It is not a youngberry. It is not a mulberry. It is not any other kind of berry, this is a black raspberry.

It drives me crazy how difficult people seem to find the concept of a black raspberry in Australia, but I digress.

Yellow, red, and black raspberries

My black raspberries have a rich complex taste and aroma. When not quite ripe it is not as sweet as my other raspberries (neither are store bought raspberries), but it is not what I would consider to be sour. When perfectly ripe they can be very sweet. They have a nice taste, it does not taste the same as a red or yellow raspberry, and it is not meant to be the same as them. It does taste a bit like a raspberry, but also very different. Black raspberry tastes nothing like a blackberry, and tastes nothing like a mulberry. There really isn't anything I have eaten that they taste similar to.

I am bad at describing taste, my description above really doesn't describe it well. The internet says black raspberries are "tangy, richly flavored, mildly sweet, cooling, and high in antioxidants". I am not sure that description is all that much better than mine.

Yellow raspberry, red raspberry, and black raspberry

You will probably notice that the berries are a bit smaller than red or yellow raspberries. My comparison photos are all typical sized berries. Some berries from each plant are larger or smaller, but the ones in the photo give you a decent idea of what is normal. While black raspberries are smaller, they are still a decent size. While I would prefer them to be larger, I don't find them to be too small.

These plants are not what I would consider to have low productivity, and they do not blow me away with the size of the crops. They usually produce clusters of about half a dozen flowers. This is comparable to most raspberry varieties including my yellow raspberries, but it feels like nothing compared to my red raspberry which produces dozens per cluster.

In my garden my red raspberries have the longest picking season. They start ripening first, finish last, and produce the most berries over the season. My yellow raspberries start to ripen after the red raspberries have been cropping for a while. My black raspberries start to crop once I have been picking both the red and yellow for a few weeks.

Black raspberries grow well in my garden, but they need different management to red raspberries. They have curved thorns, similar to a blackberry or a rose, and the thorns seems to grab at you when you walk past the plants. This is worth noting if you want to grow one.

I grow mine in pots, they appear to do well in pots. I have never had red or yellow raspberries perform well in pots for me.

Black raspberries grow differently to red raspberries. Red raspberries grow roots underground and send up canes from the tips of these roots, black raspberries do not do this. Black raspberries will set down roots from the tips of the canes if they touch the soil.

My black raspberries are a floricane variety, meaning that they flower and fruit on the previous season's growth. This is good to know as it dictates the way you prune them.

I don't prune mine at all and at this stage, but if I was pruning them I would need to ensure large canes from the previous year were intact so they could flower. I imagine that tip pruning would encourage them to branch and be more fruitful. I know that tip pruning my red or yellow raspberries increases the crop significantly as they produce 5 to 10 times as many flowers.

Much like my other raspberries, the black raspberries do not ripen all at once. Each cluster will have some ripe berries and some unripe berries at the same time. I pick them once ripe, and go back each day or so to pick more over the season. A long picking season is great for home gardeners, but dreadful for commercial growers who have to employ pickers.

It is simple to tell when the berries are ripe because they are black. The berries start out green, turn red, and get darker until they ripen a black colour. Ripe berries will pull away from the stem easily, if they resist pulling from the stem they usually aren't ripe enough. Raspberries have a hollow core once picked, blackberries and youngberries etc do not have this hollow core.

So far birds seem uninterested in my raspberries of any colour. They also don't seem overly interested in my strawberries. Perhaps I am just lucky, or perhaps the birds are too busy stealing all of my plums and apples to worry about berries.

My black raspberries seem to have more seeds than red raspberries. Perhaps it isn't more seeds, perhaps they are larger seeds. I am not sure, all I know is they are more noticeable. I don't find the seeds very annoying, but they do get stuck between my teeth more often than the seeds from my red raspberries.

Black raspberries are simple to grow from seed, but it takes a long time before you get the first crop. I am growing out some seed at the moment, and once berry season is over I plan to root some of the can tips.

If I have a few extra plants I plan to offer them on my for sale page. I don't have any spare plants at the moment but I am expecting to have a few to offer when they are dormant in winter or early spring.

Raspberry comparison

Recommended Tools for Growing Raspberries

Many of you ask what gear I use to manage my berry patches, prune the canes, and check the soil. Below are the specific, reliable tools I rely on every week.

Some links in this post are affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Felco F-2 Classic Manual Pruning Shears

The absolute industry standard for a reason. Raspberries require regular pruning to remove old fruited canes and keep the patch manageable. I use these shears because they give a clean, effortless cut without crushing the canes, preventing disease from entering the plant. They last a lifetime because every single part is replaceable.

Best for: Clean pruning of autumn and summer-fruiting raspberry canes.

👉 Check current price for Felco F-2 Shears on Amazon

Stainless Steel Soil Moisture & pH Meter
Raspberries thrive best in slightly acidic, well-draining soil. If your soil is too alkaline, your raspberries will struggle to absorb nutrients and the leaves will turn yellow. This simple, tool helps me instantly check my soil pH and moisture levels around the berry patches before applying mulch or fertilisers.