How My Continuous Brew Kombucha Survives a Freezing Winter: The 2 Vessel Method
Most kombucha instructions tell you that your culture needs warmth. Many recommend always keeping fermentation above about 18°C, and some people go considerably further, claiming that below this temperature the SCOBY will eventually die and that cold fermentation inevitably leads to mold.
I'm happy to say, this has not been my experience. If the absolute requirement to keep kombucha above 18C otherwise it ends poorly was universally true, then kombucha would probably not have been made for generations of people in Siberia.
I make kombucha at home using a traditional continuous brew method. Kombucha is expensive to buy, but very inexpensive to make. I like the taste, there are benefits to feed kombucha to poultry, plus there are purported health benefits associated with people drinking it, so I like to keep brewing kombucha all year.
My house gets very cold over winter. On some winter nights, I've observed the temperature in my kitchen drops to around 3°C, and on some days it doesn't get into double digits. I am talking about the temperature inside my kitchen, obviously the temperature outside my house gets considerably colder. For weeks at a time, the indoor temperature can stay below 15°C. I am too cheap to buy kombucha, meaning I am also too cheap to heat my kombucha, luckily it does not appear to need any heating to keep it going.
I forgot to take a photo of my thermometer on the cooler days, but the temperature peaked at around 11°C outside just after mid day, and the temperature inside the house had only reached 13.8C. This thermometer was in the same room as our fireplace with a fire that had been on all day, so the kitchen where my kombucha lives would have been cooler. These temperatures are considerably below the usual recommended fermentation temperatures, which makes it interesting that my culture continues to function.
Even though it is cold, my kombucha doesn't die, and it doesn't simply sit dormant until spring. It continues to ferment throughout winter. It ferments slower when it is cold, and faster when the weather warms up, but it keeps going year round with no heat. I've been running continuous brew kombucha since 2016, and I have never had a problem with mold.
This doesn't mean that kombucha magically prefers freezing temperatures, or that every SCOBY will behave like mine. It does mean that the idea that fermentation simply stops below 18°C, or that the SCOBY always dies in colder conditions, or that mold is inevitable with cooler temperatures, isn't true.
I used to wonder if I had somehow ended up with an unusually tough, cold hardy strain of Chaynyy Grib чайный гриб. My culture is now many years old, so perhaps it really is unusually resilient. But I think there is another important part of the explanation.
My continuous brew isn't topped up a little bit every day. Instead, I use a simple, traditional cycle where I remove an amount of mature kombucha and replace it with fresh sweet tea every 3 days or so. This means that even in the middle of winter, my main vessel always contains a large amount of established, acidic kombucha.
My continuous-brew system uses two vessels, each with a different purpose.
Vessel 1 is my main fermentation jar. This is a large 8-litre glass jar fitted with a spigot. We never drink directly from this jar. It stays in use as the main fermentation vessel, retaining most of its mature kombucha between refills.
Every three days or so, I draw off 2 litres through the spigot. This goes into my second vessel, which consists of separate drinking jars.
Vessel 2 is where the finished kombucha goes. Sometimes it is one large vessel, other times it is several smaller jars. We drink from these jars until they are empty. Meanwhile, the main fermentation jar continues doing its thing. Once I've removed the 2 litres, I replace it with 2 litres of fresh, cool sweet tea.
This means my main vessel always retains approximately 6 litres of mature kombucha before each refill. I'm never emptying the main jar, starting a new batch, or drinking directly from the fermentation vessel. It's a continuous cycle of removing finished kombucha, replacing it with fresh tea, and allowing the culture to keep working.
| Some days the temperature outside remained low |
My 8 Litre Continuous Brew
I use a very simple, traditional, continuous brew method for kombucha. My main fermentation vessel is a large glass jar that holds approximately 8 litres when full. It has a spigot at the bottom, which makes it easy to remove the finished kombucha without disturbing the jar.
As I mentioned earlier, I remove 2 litres every three days or so and transfer this into my drinking jars (vessel 2). I then replace that 2 litres with fresh, cool sweet tea.
Each time I refill the jar, I'm replacing approximately 25% of its contents. The remaining 6 litres of mature kombucha stay in the main vessel, ready for the next cycle.
In other words:
- 8 litres total capacity
- 2 litres removed every three days (this goes in the second vessel, and we drink from it)
- 2 litres of fresh sweet tea added
- Approximately 6 litres of mature kombucha remains
- The fresh tea makes up about 25% of the total volume
This simple ratio has worked for me for years, so I haven't seen any reason to change it.
Why I Think This Helps in Winter
Many online instructions recommend adding 10% starter to 90% tea. I use closer to 75% mature kombucha (as starter) to 25% fresh tea, and after years of doing this I haven't had the problems I often see people describing.
There is an obvious difference between the newer popular method of starting a jar of sweet tea with a small amount of starter and hoping the culture gets going quickly enough, and my traditional method of using a lot of starter and feeding it a little tea.
When I add 2 litres of fresh sweet tea to 6 litres of mature kombucha, the new tea is immediately mixed with a much larger volume of established fermented liquid. The fresh tea isn't sitting there by itself waiting for the culture to get started. It is being added to an already active fermentation environment containing a large population of microorganisms and a substantial amount of acidic liquid. I suspect this is particularly useful during winter, when everything is happening more slowly.
At warm temperatures, the culture can acidify fresh tea relatively quickly. Below 10°C, everything happens much more slowly. Rather than relying on the culture to rapidly establish itself in a large percentage of fresh sweet tea, I start with a much larger proportion of mature kombucha.
The kombucha slows down when the weather gets cold. It doesn't behave like it does during summer, but it doesn't stop either. It continues fermenting more slowly. When the weather warms up, fermentation speeds up again. Like my other ferments, it changes with the seasons.
![]() |
| 8L kombucha in a jar |
Why I Don't Top It Up Every Day
I think another advantage of my system is that I leave the main vessel alone between refills.
Every three days or so, I remove 2 litres and replace it with 2 litres of fresh sweet tea. Then I leave it alone until the next refill.
I don't continually dip into the jar or add small amounts of fresh tea throughout the week. I prefer to work in these larger, predictable cycles.
It is a very simple system, it's the way kombucha was traditionally made for generations, and I've found that simple works particularly well when the weather gets cold.
Has My Kombucha Actually Adapted to the Cold?
This is something I've wondered about for years.
I've been maintaining this culture for years, and it has gone through many cold winters in my house. Perhaps the microorganisms in my culture really have become particularly well suited to these conditions.
It is certainly possible that a microbial community repeatedly exposed to the same environmental conditions could change over time. I think of the idea of a particularly cold hardy “Siberian” kombucha culture as an interesting possibility, although I have no way of knowing whether that's actually happened.
There is another, much simpler explanation. Perhaps the large reservoir of mature kombucha helps keep the environment unsuitable for mould.
![]() |
| More kombucha, this jar lives in my cold garage |
Why Doesn't My Kombucha Get Mouldy?
I've never had a mould problem with this continuous-brew vessel, despite maintaining it through many cold winters.
I suspect that several things contribute to this. The large proportion of mature kombucha means that every refill starts with an established acidic environment. The microbial community is already well established, and I'm not repeatedly starting large quantities of fresh sweet tea from scratch.
However, I wouldn't claim that this method makes kombucha immune to mould. Contamination is still possible, and cold temperatures don't eliminate the need for clean equipment and sensible fermentation practices.
All I can really say is that this particular system has worked exceptionally well for me over many years.
What I Do During the Coldest Part of Winter
In winter, I keep following the same basic routine that I follow for the rest of the year. Every three days I remove 2 litres, keep it aside for drinking, and replace it with 2 litres of cool sweet tea.
In winter the fermentation is slower, so the finished drink can behave differently from my summer kombucha. But the culture itself continues through the winter.
I don't use a heating mat or heated fermentation wrap. I don't move the jar into a warm room or wrap it in a towel. I don't try to maintain a particular temperature. I just let the culture slow down naturally, and it hasn't yet had any problems.
And after doing this for years, through many winters where my kitchen has dropped to temperatures that most kombucha instructions would consider far too cold, I've still never had a single problem with mould in this vessel.
Would This Work for Everyone?
While I don't see why not, there is no way for me to know for sure.
There are too many variables involved in kombucha: the culture itself, the recipe, the acidity, the amount of starter liquid, the cleanliness of the equipment, the temperature fluctuations, the size and shape of the vessel, etc. While my method has worked for me and I've been doing it consistently for years, my jar has had years to establish itself, and I can't comment on what your kitchen is like.
I don't know whether the secret is the large proportion of mature kombucha, the particular microbial community I've maintained for all these years, blind luck, or some combination of all three.
Maybe my old culture really is unusually tough. Maybe the simple '6 litres of mature kombucha to 2 litres of fresh tea' ratio is doing all the work. Or maybe kombucha is simply more resilient than many modern instructions make it sound.
Whatever the explanation, I find it fascinating that my kombucha continues fermenting through winters when my kitchen temperatures are far below the usual recommendations. After nearly a decade of doing it this way, I'm certainly not about to start heating it.
Where To Get a Kombucha SCOBY
If you would like to make kombucha at home you will need a SCOBY. I sometimes sell my kombucha cultures through my for sale page. Mine are taken from the same continuous brew system I have been maintaining for years.
If I don't have any kombucha cultures available for sale, or if you're outside Australia, you can also purchase a kombucha starter culture from Bacillus Bulgaricus. This is an affiliate link, so if you buy through it I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I haven't bought their kombucha starter myself, but I have bought several of their other cultures and they have all worked well for me.



No comments:
Post a Comment